France, Panama and several other countries are demanding that the final COP31 agreement include a “clear transition away from fossil fuels,” after the latest draft omitted coal, oil and gas entirely. With the conference scheduled to close Friday evening in Antalya, Turkey, Panama is threatening to block a text that leaves out a gradual fossil fuel exit and the importance of climate science. France has stopped short of that ultimatum.

Presented at a midday news conference Friday, their joint declaration has around 10 signatories, including Spain, Belgium, the Solomon Islands and Ivory Coast. It also demands “clean and immediate electrification”: the draft circulated the previous day called for electrification without specifying that the electricity should be clean. Faced with the energy crisis, the signatories want a faster transition away from fossil fuels and road maps to deliver it.

At stake is whether an existing commitment survives. At COP28 in Dubai in 2023, countries agreed to a “transition away from fossil fuels,” which account for the overwhelming majority of human-caused greenhouse gas emissions. Since then, Saudi Arabia and Russia have worked to keep the subject out of the negotiations. The latest draft framework decision, under dispute since Thursday, contains no reference to it.

French Ecological Transition Minister Monique Barbut calls that omission a “black mark.” By contrast, she points to “four paragraphs” devoted to carbon capture and storage, a technology promoted by oil companies that she regards as a distraction from cutting CO₂ emissions. Vanuatu’s environment minister, Ralph Regenvanu, also says the document gives the technology “special attention it does not deserve.”

The dispute also concerns who should pay. The signatories say both those historically responsible for global warming and those contributing to it today must help solve the problem and bear the cost. Without naming them, this call to broaden the climate finance contributor base targets China, the world’s largest greenhouse gas emitter, and the Gulf’s oil monarchies.

The European Union has spent years seeking a revision of the list of countries required to fund climate assistance, drawn up in 1992 when the United Nations climate convention was created. Its argument is that “the world has changed since then.” The EU is the largest global contributor of public climate finance for developing countries, providing €32.3 billion in 2025.

But France’s position has drawn a blistering attack from Mohamed Adow, director of Power Shift Africa. “France has behaved in an utterly contemptible manner here at COP31,” he says. He accuses Paris of telling vulnerable African countries privately that they would receive “not a cent of climate finance,” while publicly blaming them for the negotiating deadlock on the grounds that they were not moving away from fossil fuels fast enough. He says France is treating those nations like “an oppressive colonial power,” rather than a country presenting itself as a climate champion.

Some poor countries more broadly accuse the EU of obstructing negotiations by refusing to put a precise figure on its assistance for adapting to climate change. Arriving in Antalya after finding itself heavily isolated as a funder at last year’s Brazilian COP, the EU had declared any discussion of a new financial commitment “doomed to fail.” This year it is emphasizing access to finance and better use of existing money rather than a new financial pledge.

The declaration also demands “a strong signal to accelerate methane emissions reductions,” another French priority. Methane is responsible for roughly a third of current warming and has more than 80 times the warming effect of CO₂ over 20 years, but remains in the atmosphere for only about a decade. Cutting its emissions can therefore slow warming quickly.

The signatories focus particularly on the oil and gas industry, where those reductions are relatively straightforward and inexpensive. They want major emitters to detect and repair leaks promptly and eliminate routine flaring and venting—the habitual burning or release of gas.

A final fault line concerns the scientific timetable. The declaration calls science the “foundation for action” and says every decision must draw on the best available knowledge, including the findings of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, or IPCC. It supports the panel’s co-chairs’ proposal to publish all three reports in its seventh assessment cycle before the second global stocktake of climate action, and calls for the panel to be fully funded and supported.

Publication in 2028 would allow the reports to inform that stocktake. Saudi Arabia and India want to postpone publication until 2029. The COP31 presidency has announced a third draft agreement for later Friday, while negotiations could spill into the weekend. One consequential distinction remains: Panama has threatened to block adoption; France is seeking the same direction without, so far, making it such an absolute condition.