Removing a supermarket scale’s plastic tray can lower the displayed price without exposing any overcharging: the machine’s settings already subtract the tray’s weight. Yet a viral video filmed at an E. Leclerc store in Gironde presents the maneuver as evidence that customers are being cheated on the price of tomatoes.

Viewed just over a million times in two days on TikTok, the clip shows a customer weighing tomatoes with a displayed price of €2.14. She then removes the plastic tray and announces a different amount: “And now it comes to €1.42 for the same quantity.” Presented as a “little money-saving tip at supermarkets,” the maneuver drew indignant comments, including “It’s theft,” “We need a petition” and “We’re being taken for fools.”

The tray’s main purpose is to make cleaning easier, E. Leclerc explains. Its weight is accounted for through the scale’s tare setting: “The weight has been adjusted accordingly so customers are not shortchanged: with the tray, the weight is zero kilograms; without it, the empty weight is negative.”

Removing the tray does not change the mass of the tomatoes. It removes a weight that the scale is already set to subtract. The displayed net weight therefore falls below the weight of the produce actually on the scale. On that explanation, the maneuver here amounts to not paying for roughly 180 grams of tomatoes, rather than correcting an overcharge.

The video also has an important limitation: it does not show the scale’s empty reading. It therefore does not establish that the weighing was performed correctly. The cited total of 356 grams would also amount to about 60 grams per tomato, whereas the specialty vine tomatoes visible, which are smaller than standard vine tomatoes, generally weigh around 90 grams each. That discrepancy warrants caution; it is not, by itself, a measurement of their actual weight.

Commercial scales are subject to strict regulation. Instruments used for direct sales to the public, with a maximum capacity of 30 kilograms, must undergo official verification every two years. Checks are generally conducted by organizations commissioned by the regional directorate for the economy, employment, labor and solidarity, known as DREETS. A green sticker certifies the instrument’s compliance after inspection. A store with noncompliant scales can face criminal prosecution for deception or misleading commercial practices.

Similar posts have circulated in recent months, and the accusation has resurfaced over several years. In 2023, the same “test” was performed with onions at an E. Leclerc store. The retailer gave the same explanation then as in 2026: the tray is included in the tare setting. A lower price after its removal does not demonstrate that the customer was previously paying too much.