Police officers and gendarmes will be presumed to have acted lawfully when using their weapons under legislation definitively adopted by the French Parliament on Friday evening. The measure reverses the burden of proof. Senators approved it by 205 votes to 110 without changing the version passed by the National Assembly this summer. The Senate’s left-wing opposition announced a Constitutional Council challenge aimed at blocking its enactment.
The vote came on the eve of another day of social protests. Backed by the government, much of the centrist bloc and the National Rally (RN), the bill introduced by Les Républicains (LR) lawmaker Éric Pauget has faced fierce opposition at demonstrations. Opponents call it a “license to kill” and a threat to fundamental rights.
The legislation states that, “when they use their weapons,” police officers and gendarmes “are presumed to have acted” within the law. It also specifies that “this presumption may, at any time, be overturned by any evidence to the contrary.” The additional legal protection defended by its supporters therefore rests on a rebuttable presumption, not immunity.
Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez welcomed the vote as “a mark of confidence in police officers and gendarmes.” He said the reform would provide “a legal framework suited to the reality” of their operations after months of heavy demands on officers responding to social and high school student unrest. Those protests have repeatedly descended into violence, particularly on October 17.
Accused by the entire left of yielding to a far-right proposal, Nuñez insisted that the reform belonged to “the government,” not “the National Rally.” He also maintained that it did not establish a “presumption of self-defense,” despite the bill’s official title suggesting otherwise. The government rewrote its provisions during the National Assembly’s examination this summer.
The government urgently placed the bill on the Senate’s agenda before the RN could pursue its plan to bring it forward during its allotted parliamentary time in December. Thursday evening’s exchanges were heated, with the left prolonging discussion despite accusations of “obstruction.” Debate resumed in a less tense atmosphere on Friday. The Senate’s right-wing and centrist majority rejected every amendment that could have delayed final passage.
RN Senator Sylvie Josserand claimed “a parliamentary and ideological victory.” Patrick Kanner, leader of the Socialist senators, instead described a law “contrary to the interests of our law enforcement officers” that gave Marine Le Pen “a stepping stone” to power. “This bill will serve neither police officers nor republicans who refuse to see the RN come to power,” he said.
The Green group accused Macronism of having now swept away “every republican safeguard.” Green Senator Thomas Dossus called the proposal “extremely serious” at a time when, in his assessment, French public trust in the police is collapsing. Gabriel Amard, a lawmaker from France Unbowed, put his objection this way: “With this bill, death will no longer be presumed unjust. It is the shot that will be presumed legitimate.”
Muriel Jourda, the LR chair of the Senate’s Law Committee, defended the measure by arguing that “the presumption of innocence has never prevented an investigation and has never prevented a conviction.” She, too, said she wanted to send law enforcement a message of “confidence.”
Opposition to the measure is among the many demands of organizations and associations involved in recent weeks’ demonstrations, following a petition that collected more than 700,000 signatures on the National Assembly’s website. It is set to remain central to gatherings planned across France on Saturday, called notably by unions and youth organizations.
Nuñez has warned prefects of feared repercussions after the vote. In a telegram, he asked them to be “particularly vigilant regarding the groups most hostile to law enforcement following the Senate debate.” For the government, the new legal vote of confidence in officers comes with instructions to watch closely for the reaction to it.


