Strategic voting is taking center stage in the fall debates ahead of France’s 2027 presidential election, threatening to turn opinion polls into the arbiter of political competition. Political journalist Matthieu Goar argues that the logic of the “vote utile,” or useful vote, shuts out the debate over ideas by putting a candidate’s perceived electoral chances ahead of the substance of their platform.
Yet the issue extends beyond electoral calculation. With the far right viewed as a threat to the Republic, voting also carries, in this understanding, a moral and strategic responsibility: should voters abandon their first choice to prevent an outcome they consider more dangerous? Several generations of French citizens have been called on to back someone other than their preferred candidate to build a republican barrier against the far right.
Jean-Marie Le Pen’s advance to the presidential runoff in 2002 marked this contemporary practice. Those barriers subsequently had to be rebuilt in the presidential elections of 2017 and 2022, in numerous constituencies—notably during the 2024 legislative elections—and in local elections. Increasingly fragile, they have nevertheless held at the national level. Goar gives citizens more credit for that outcome than political leaders.
His criticism targets, in particular, right-wing parties that have increasingly—and, in his assessment, deliberately—disregarded the founding rule of the republican front: withdraw in favor of the leading candidate to defeat the reactionary camp.
That rule dates to the late 19th century, when a still-fragile Republic faced royalists and those nostalgic for Bonapartism. Candidate withdrawals were intended to preserve republican government. As 2027 approaches, the tension lies between two uses of strategic voting: a means of defending the Republic, but also a logic that, when focused exclusively on polls, crowds out the contest of ideas.


