France’s National Assembly gave final approval on Thursday evening, November 19, to a two-year extension of rent controls, five days before the measure was due to expire on November 24. The rules cover 1.2 million tenants in about 70 municipalities, including Paris, Lyon, Bordeaux, and Lille.

Lawmakers approved the bill by 148 votes to 95 after tense exchanges between the left and the National Rally. To break the legislative impasse, the government invoked Article 44, paragraph 2, of the Constitution, which allows it to exclude amendments that have not been examined in committee—hundreds at a time if necessary.

Left-wing parties, MoDem, and the Liot parliamentary group backed the extension. Renaissance split between supporters and opponents, while Horizons abstained. Lawmakers from Les Républicains, the National Rally, and UDR voted against it.

Paris City Hall welcomed a “major victory.” Marie-Amandine Stévenin, president of Que Choisir Ensemble, called the decision “a relief for more than a million tenants and consumers in France.”

Socialist lawmaker Iñaki Echaniz, who steered the bill through the Assembly, and committee chair Stéphane Travert, a member of the Macron camp, jointly requested the constitutional intervention late Thursday afternoon. They sought to bypass a barrage of National Rally amendments. Such obstruction is not unique to that party: other groups, including those on the left, have used the tactic before.

Housing Minister Vincent Jeanbrun agreed to their request despite his personal opposition to rent controls. He described the debate as “bogged down in absolutely sterile obstruction.” Other parliamentary groups protested, having themselves asked the government to use the same procedure during earlier sessions reserved for their own legislation.

On the policy itself, the National Rally argues that rent controls threaten the income of “small landlords” and, in turn, weaken the rental market. Former Housing Minister Guillaume Kasbarian, a Macron ally, also challenged the measure’s usefulness: “It won’t create a single additional home; it will just make the waiting line longer.” Supporters thus welcome the preservation of tenant protections, while opponents argue that the rules reduce housing supply.

The National Rally also accused the government of striking a secret “deal” with the Socialists. The government had already devoted part of its own parliamentary time to the bill the previous Wednesday.

On Friday morning, National Rally lawmaker and spokesperson Laurent Jacobelli condemned the intervention of a Les Républicains minister to defend a Socialist bill extending a Macron-era measure. He portrayed it as evidence of a “single party” stretching from Les Républicains to the Socialist Party.

Beyond the procedural fight, the National Rally says it would change the law if Marine Le Pen is elected president. “We won’t keep it in its current form,” Jacobelli said, asserting that rent controls had reduced the number of homes offered for rent and created a shortage. The extension has passed; the dispute over its effects remains unresolved.