Intentionally blocking a high school or university, even without violence, would carry up to a year in prison and a €15,000 fine under a bill introduced on November 18 by Matthieu Bloch, the UDR lawmaker for the Doubs department’s third constituency. Bloch says he wants to protect the freedom to study. Lawyers in Besançon question whether the measure could be applied in practice and fear its main effect would be to facilitate police custody as a deterrent to young protesters.

The bill follows high school protests and comes as university blockades persist from Paris to Besançon. It would create a specific offense of obstructing the freedom to study, with penalties rising to three years in prison and a €45,000 fine when threats, violence or property damage are involved.

Bloch argues that the freedom to protest must not prevent other students from reaching their classrooms. He says conversations with the public led him to a “simple observation”: “institutions are being blocked even though a majority of students want to get into classrooms.” He points in particular to families in the Montbéliard area of his constituency who “make enormous sacrifices to give their children access to higher education.”

The lawmaker is also pressing the government to act. Education Minister Édouard Geffray has repeatedly stated in recent days that blockades are illegal. Bloch wants to add criminal penalties to the university disciplinary sanctions that have so far been imposed for these blockades.

But how would responsibility be assigned within a crowd? Florent Diaz, a Besançon lawyer specializing in criminal and immigration law, has repeatedly defended young people held in police custody following arrests on the sidelines of protests. He sees nothing new in the initiative: similar bills have previously been introduced without making it through Parliament, he says, notably because they would be impractical to enforce.

“Who is the person blocking the entrance?” he asks. “The one holding the barricade? The one smoking a cigarette next to it?” This fall, Diaz has sometimes seen 200 high school students barricading entrances to schools in Besançon. He questions the logic of arresting 200 minors and sending them all before a juvenile court. In his view, the difficulty of proving individual responsibility would leave the law unenforced: an announcement with little practical substance.

Yet the possible absence of convictions would not mean an absence of immediate consequences. Diaz notes that an offense punishable by a year in prison allows suspects to be held in police custody. He fears the provision could therefore be used to take people away from a blockade even if their individual responsibility could not subsequently be established.

That prospect has led the Besançon rights group Défense de rupture to denounce the proposal as a measure designed to frighten protesters. Its co-president, lawyer Mia Matencio, notes that more than 200 arrests have taken place on the sidelines of protests in Besançon, according to the prefecture, while very few have led to prosecutions. Under that approach, she argues, “the investigation becomes the punishment”: police custody, and the trauma it can cause, serve to discourage young people from protesting again.

The civil liberties group opposes this “normalization of criminal law,” in which deprivation of liberty would cease to be a last resort reserved for serious offenses. Matencio instead calls for examining the structural causes of the protests and providing a political response. Where Bloch seeks to guarantee access to classes in the face of blockades, she emphasizes an ambition shared by all these students: a quality education. The disagreement also concerns the instrument chosen—a new criminal penalty whose deterrent effect, the lawyers fear, would begin in police custody, before any judgment.